Caravaggio: a Murderous Artist

The personalities featured on the blog this week do nothing to debunk the idea of artists having fiery temperaments. On Tuesday, we told the tale of Baroque architect Francesco Borromini, whose bitter rivalry with fellow artist Bernini is thought to have led to his tragic suicide. Today, we have another dramatic life story and another Baroque artist – Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio – who was born on 29 September 1571.

The Taking of Christ, Caravaggio, courtesy of the National Gallery of Ireland, under a CC-BY-NC-ND licence

The Taking of Christ, Caravaggio, courtesy of the National Gallery of Ireland, under a CC-BY-NC-ND licence

Did you know?

Here are five things that you might not know about Caravaggio (from FT.com):

PLAGUE: He lost most of his family to the plague that devastated Milan in 1577, when he was just six years old.

VIOLENCE: He was a dangerous man whose violent attacks held a particular kind of logic: a waiter who questioned his taste was rewarded with a plate in the face; a man who insulted Caravaggio behind his back was in turn attacked from behind with a sword.

MURDER: Caravaggio fought a pre-arranged duel with a man named Tomassoni. The quarrel is thought to have been over a woman, Tomassoni’s wife. The fight was to the death and Caravaggio won.

INSULT: The Santa Maria del Popolo in Rome houses a Caravaggio painting, The Conversion of St Paul, and a rather clever insult to a rival artist, Carracci, whose Madonna is displayed in the same church. In Caravaggio’s painting, the rear of St Paul’s horse is pointed quite deliberately towards the face of the Madonna in Carracci’s work.

REVENGE: Caravaggio met his death when a man seeking revenge for an earlier attack slashed Caravaggio’s face with a knife. The injuries were so bad that Caravaggio was virtually unrecognisable. The painter never fully recovered and died a few months later, in 1610.

David with the Head of Goliath, Caravaggio, courtesy of the Kunsthistorisches Museum

Caravaggio has a particular significance to Europeana as his David with the Head of Goliath (Kunsthistorisches Museum) represented a content milestone, and was the Austrian Culture Minister’s Europeana pick earlier this year.

The Baroque style, which used exaggerated motion and clear, easily interpreted detail to produce drama and grandeur, was encouraged by the Roman Catholic Church, which wanted the arts to convey religious themes and encourage direct emotional involvement. Did the movement’s  emphasis on exaggeration, emotion and drama stoke the fire of Carvaggio’s violence? Or did the existence of a vicious temperament lead the man to be a great artist, second only to Michelangelo in terms of Italian art influence? One thing is clear – his experience of real-life horrors and a dispensation for violence is borne out in his work. His commissions included religious works featuring ‘violent struggles, grotesque decapitations, torture and death’ (Caravaggio Foundation).

Despite a relatively short career – he died at the age of 38 – Caravaggio’s work had a huge influence on the younger artists in Rome at the time. ‘Caravaggism’ became a new style followed by a school of painters termed the ‘Caravaggisti’. Pockets of Caravaggisti sprang up in Rome, Naples and the Utrecht (characteristics of his work can be seen in paintings by Rubens, Vermeer, Rembrandt and Velázquez) but were largely short-lived. It was not until the 20th century that the significance of Caravaggio’s work to Western art was widely acknowledged.

David and Goliath by Borgianni (one of the second wave of Caraviggisti), courtesy of CER:ES, public domain image.

Another depiction of David and Goliath, this one by Borgianni (one of the second wave of Caraviggisti), courtesy of CER:ES, public domain image.

 

 

2 thoughts on “Caravaggio: a Murderous Artist

  1. In my views, Caravaggio, was a dangerous man whose violent attacks held a particular kind of logic: a waiter who questioned his taste was rewarded with a plate in the face; a man who insulted Caravaggio behind his back was in turn attacked from behind with a sword.

    Caravaggio fought a pre-arranged duel with a man named Tomassoni. The quarrel is thought to have been over a woman, Tomassoni’s wife. The fight was to the death and Caravaggio won.

    He was really a protagonist to be saluted …

  2. Thank you very much for sharing this very interesting article!
    No, I need knew none of the stated facts about Caravaggio before reading your post. And the article together with the pictures have led me to read a lot more about this great artist. Thanks again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.